Wood vs Vinyl Siding: What’s Best for Your House?

Wood is a popular siding material used in homes across the country, and has been so for hundreds of years. Wood siding is preferred by many as it is strong, long lasting, great to look at and is something that will never go out of fashion. It is available in several different styles and designs such as shingles, shakes, clapboards and board and batten.

vinyl vs wood siding

Vinyl siding is an excellent alternative to wood siding. Unlike wood siding, it is a man-made material which is made from binders, fibers and fillers. The materials used in the construction of vinyl sidings are heated and compressed into boards so that they have the same appearance as wood sidings.

Vinyl sidings are the most popular choice in homes across the United States because vinyl is cheap, durable and requires little or no maintenance. It is available is a variety of designs such as shingles, shakes, board and batten and clapboards.

Let’s do a quick comparison of wood siding with vinyl siding. 

Wood vs Vinyl Siding: Which is better for your house?

 How Much Does Wood Siding Cost?

The cost of wood siding varies depending on the quality or type of the wood. Engineered wood or composite wood costs between $4 and $6.50 per sq. foot. Cedar or solid wood costs between $5 and $10 per sq. foot.

 How Much Does Vinyl Siding Cost?

Vinyl siding costs less than wood siding: $2 and $7 per square foot. The cost of vinyl siding will depend on the quality and thickness of the vinyl. Mind you, the rates for both wood and vinyl siding can differ depending on where you are based in the USA.

The Case for Wood Siding

#1: Wood siding is very durable and will last for decades to come – as long as it is maintained well.

#2: Wood siding looks really attractive and certainly makes your house stand out in the crowd, when you consider that most homes have vinyl siding. Wood has a classy, natural look to it, and is aesthetically pleasing.

#3:  Homes with wood siding fetch a higher resale value than those with vinyl siding.

The Case against Wood Siding

#1: Wood siding is more expensive than vinyl siding.

#2: It does require a lot of maintenance. You will need to repaint and stain the wood every few years to maintain it in a decent condition.

#3: Wood is vulnerable to damage from termites, carpenter ants and other pests and insects.

The Case for Vinyl Siding

#1: As explained earlier, vinyl siding costs less than wood siding. Vinyl is a very affordable material. This is also one reason why it is so popular. More homes have vinyl siding than wood siding in the United States.

#2: It requires little or no maintenance, unlike wood siding. You don’t need to refinish, sand or repaint vinyl – in fact, you can’t repaint vinyl siding. You might need to have it cleaned occasionally, but that’s about it.

#3: Vinyl cannot be damaged by pests such as carpenter ants and termites.

The Case against Vinyl Siding 

#1: Vinyl can never be as stylish or classy as wood, although it looks pretty much the same.

#2: Vinyl siding is susceptible to high temperatures and can get brittle over time.

#3: Vinyl siding can get damaged if left exposed to the heat from a grill or outdoor kitchen.

Conclusion – Wood vs. Vinyl Siding

Vinyl siding costs less than wood siding, requires no maintenance and cannot be damaged by wood-eating pests such as termites and carpenter ants. But wood siding has more curb appeal and is certainly classier than vinyl siding.